The Lady With The Pet Dog Analysis - 1570 Words

â€Å"Then they spent a long time taking counsel together, they talked of how to avoid the necessity for secrecy, for deception, for living in different cities, and not seeing one another for long stretches of time. How could they free themselves from these intolerable fetters?† (Chekhov 224). In 1899, Anton Chekhov wrote â€Å"The Lady with the Pet Dog† which tells the story of Dmitry Dmitrich Gurov and Anna Sergeyevna von Didertiz’s love affair through the man’s point of view. It is hopeless and immoral, but it is a love that knows no bounds. In 1972, Joyce Carol Oates gave new life to the lover’s story through the woman’s point of view in her story â€Å"The Lady with the Pet Dog.† Although both stories use the same plot and title, there are both†¦show more content†¦On the other hand, Oates’ retelling takes place in Nantucket, Massachusetts; Albany, New York, and Ohio. It is clear that Nantucket is supposed to be th e United States’ own version of Yalta; however, less emphasis is put on the beauty of it. Instead, Oates chooses to highlight its tourism and romanticism. When the couple is walking around the town, they look â€Å"at the other strollers, the weekend visitors, the tourists, the couples like themselves† (Oates 235). As a result, the magic of Yalta is lost in Nantucket, and part of the romantic aspect is gone, too. Additionally, a year it takes place is never specified, but based on the year it was written--1972--it probably is somewhere around the late 1900s. This means it happens during more modern times, and consequently, it is more difficult to feel for the lovers as they live in a time when divorce is more accessible and accepted. Of course, they have their own reasons for staying with their spouses, but compared to Chekhov’s story, their romance is definitely less tragic in that regard. Because Chekhov’s story is more sensible and understandable in te rms of setting, this is just one area that proves his story is the better of the two. Furthermore, while there are some comparisons in characters, Chekhov and Oates have ultimately created characters unique to their stories. In both stories, the girl’s name is Anna, and both her and the man are married to other people. OneShow MoreRelatedThe Lady With The Pet Dog Character Analysis1481 Words   |  6 PagesLiterary analysis is a key component in understanding all of the depth and story behind a piece of work. Literary analysis, allows for more complexity and involvement; which is why it is crucial for the reader to understand what to be looking for when reading a piece of work. To not be aware of literary analysis and what it entails only hinders the reader and lessens the impact of the work that the reader is engaged in. In this paper I will be covering the topic of whether the character Gurov inRead MoreJoyce Carol Oates The Lady With The Pet Dog Analysis1101 Words   |  5 Pages In Joyce Carol Oates’ story entitled â€Å"The Lady with the Pet Dog,† the main character Anna fits Sigmund Freud’s definition of neurotic: â€Å"the ego and id become involved in an internal battle Freud calls neurosis† (Bressler 130). In addition to the ego and id, Anna’s superego also comes into play within her struggle. Throughout Oates’ story, the reader sees Anna’s internal conflict between the id, which dominates her personality, the ego, and the superego, which results in her neurosis. Oates makesRead MoreAnalysis Of The Short Stories Lady With A Pet Dog 1021 Words   |  5 PagesHope Crenshaw Dr. Schott English 102 September 13,2015 â€Å"Lady with the Pet Dog† The short stories â€Å"Lady with the Pet Dog† written by Chekov and â€Å"Lady with a Pet Dog† written by Oates demonstrate the relationship between a young woman, Anna , and her lover. The authors use two different points of view as well asRead MorePsychological Analysis of Anton Chekhovs the Lady with the Pet Dog1981 Words   |  8 PagesPsychological Analysis of Anton Chekhov’s The Lady with the Pet Dog In Anton Chekhov’s short story, The Lady with the pet Dog, Dmitry Dmitrich Gurov and Anna Sergeyevna are bound together, not by love, but by their psychological needs. Both need to believe in a phenomenon deeper and more meaningful than each of their despised lives and for this reason; they think the intimacy between them, fueled by desperation, is love. . In reality, the relationship between Gurov and Anna is characterizedRead MoreUnderstanding Relationships in Emily Dickinsons Because I Could Not Stop for Death and John Updikes Dogs Death1796 Words   |  7 Pagesget a more complex understanding of relationships that develop between individuals who truly comprehend the importance of love. To a certain degree one might feel inclined to consider that the protagonist in Dickinsons poem is very similar to the dog in Updikes poem, taking into account that they both employ a protective attitude regarding their loved ones in spite of the fact that they suffer greatly on the insi de. People rarely have time to enjoy their last moments and it is even more difficultRead MorePichelman vs. Barfknecht Essay770 Words   |  4 Pageswas also engaged in recreational activity. Analysis: The statute 895.52 provides immunity from liability for any owners of wild animals causing injuries on their property, however, it is questionable as to whether the raccoon is really considered a wild animal simply because other members of its species run free and are perceived as being un-predictable at times. The Barfknechts defend themselves by saying that â€Å"the fact that Babe was something of a pet does not take him out of the category of feraeRead MoreAnimal Cruelty and Human Violence2076 Words   |  9 Pagesthe proper necessities: food, water, attention, shelter, grooming, or veterinary care. In these instances the neglect is because of acts of omission rather than commission and does not give the neglectful owner satisfaction . The neighborhood cat lady would be an example of neglectful behavior because she, as the owner, has more animals than she can afford and therefore is unable to give them the proper necessities mentioned earlier in the paragraph. The fou rth and final definition of animal crueltyRead MoreIrresponsible Love in Anton Chekhov’s The Lady with the Dog1797 Words   |  8 Pages Anton Chekhov’s The Lady with the Pet Dog can be said to be one of the most controversial fictions in the way it the extramarital affairs and the mystery of love that plagues the 21st century families. By the use of imaginary characters, Chekhov explores the theme of immorality and irresponsible behaviors among married couples who seek real satisfaction in secrete yet intimate relationships with other married partners. Whereas the likes of Gurov poses as the spoilt seed of the collapsing societyRead MoreShould Smoking Be Banned Public Places?941 Words   |  4 Pages11, 1964. The committee concluded that cigarette smoking was a cause of lung cancer and laryngeal cancer in men, a probable cause of lung cancer in women, and the most important cause of chronic bronchitis (cdc.com). According to a retrospective analysis of data from 192 countries approximately 21,000 deaths of lung cancer could be attributed to second hand smoking (Pallis, et al. 494). Emphysema is another smo king related disease, which is a type of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. StudiesRead MoreAnalysis of The Stolen Party by Liliana Heker1558 Words   |  7 Pages An Analysis of Liliana Hekers â€Å"The Stolen Party† Destiny Hailei Fincher October 7, 2014 English 1302 The author of the story The Stolen Party, Lilian Heker, was born on February 9, 1943 in Buenos Aires, Argentina. Hekers career began at the age of 17 when she met Abelardo Castillo. Castillo was writer and chief of the literary periodical, who introduced Heker as an editor to a magazine. In 1966 Heker published her first collection of short stories, Los que vieron la zarza. In 1972 she published